Manhattan Transfer
"Oh I know everything is dead." So says Billy Waldron to Ruth Prynne in chapter two, 'Nickelodeon,' of the third section of John Dos Passos' 'Manhattan Transfer'. This statement embodies several techniques Dos Passos uses throughout his novel - such as an almost insignificant 'throwaway' line of dialogue, a dour comment, an observation made about people which is representative of the city as a whole, an instance of foreshadowing whose importance comes into play later on techniques that sometimes linger for only a scene before their pay-off arrives, while others linger for the span of several chapters before we understand their purpose.
"Oh I know everything is dead." Billy speaks these words after Ruth tells him she has "had a terrible run of bad luck." We are sympathetic towards Ruth - she has a sore throat, she feels "like the wrath of God," and then when she runs into her old friend Billy and he tells her he has not heard from her in a good while, she knows he has put her down "as a back number." She is not in the best of health, feels tired, has been cut off from a former companion, and has fallen on hard times. However, rather than allaying Ruth's bad luck or ill health, and rather than allowing this reunion between Billy and Ruth to delve into sentimental reminiscences on good times now past, the author twists the screw in further after Ruth confesses to Billy she has had her throat x-rayed. "Ruth I wish you werent taking that X-ray treatment," Billy tells her. "I've heard it's very dangerous. Don't let me alarm you about it my dear... but I have heard of cases of cancer contracted that way." Ruth brushes it off as "nonsense," but later, "sitting in the uptown express in the subway," her fears play on her. "She looked up and down the car at the joggling faces opposite her. Of all those people one of them must have it. FOUR OUT OF EVERY FIVE GET... She put her hand to her throat. Her throat was terribly swollen. ...Maybe it was worse. It is something...
View Full Essay